The play, originally scheduled to run until June 10, 2007, was extended to July 1, 2007, with a new cast - original New York cast member as Helen, as Tom, as Carter, and as Jeannie.
Tom is taken with her brash acceptance of the way people see her and her in-your-face honesty.
He asks her for her phone number and they start to date.
.
McPhee, Barry, and Lumley were all nominated for for the well-received production.
It was directed by Matthew Decker and featured Ed Renninger as Tom, Melissa Joy Hart as Helen, Paul Felder as Carter and Erin Mulgrew as Jeannie.